Present- |
Council Members Campbell, Golonski, Murphy, Vander Borght and Ramos. |
Absent - - - - |
Council Members None. |
Also Present - |
Ms. Alvord, City Manager; Mr. Barlow, City Attorney; and, Mrs. Campos,
City Clerk.
|
Oral
Communications |
There was no response to the Mayor�s invitation for oral communications on
Closed Session matters at this time.
|
5:05 P.M.
Recess |
The Council recessed at this time to the City Hall Basement Lunch
Room/Conference Room to hold a Closed Session on the following:
|
|
a. Conference with Legal Counsel � Anticipated Litigation (City as
possible plaintiff):
Pursuant to Govt. Code �54956.9(c)
Number of potential case(s): 1
|
|
b. Conference with Legal Counsel � Anticipated Litigation (City as
potential defendant):
Pursuant to Govt. Code �54956.9(b)(1)
Number of potential case(s): 1
|
|
c. Conference with Labor Negotiator:
Pursuant to Govt. Code �54957.6
Name
of the Agency Negotiator:
Management Services Director/Judie Sarquiz.
Name of Organization Representing Employee:
Represented: Burbank City Employees Association, Burbank Management
Association, Burbank Firefighters Chief Officers Unit, and Burbank Police
Officers Association; Unrepresented, and Appointed Officials.
Summary of Labor Issues to be Negotiated:
Current Contracts and Retirement Issues.
|
Regular Meeting
Reconvened in
Council Chambers |
The regular meeting of the Council of the City of Burbank was reconvened
at 6:38 p.m. by Mrs. Ramos, Mayor.
|
Invocation
|
The invocation was given by Mr. Kramer, Community Assistance Coordinator.
|
Flag Salute
ROLL CALL |
The pledge of allegiance to the flag was led by Eva Sippel.
|
Present- |
Council Members Campbell, Golonski, Murphy, Vander Borght and Ramos. |
Absent - - - - |
Council Members None. |
Also Present - |
Ms. Alvord, City Manager; Mr. Barlow, City Attorney; and, Mrs. Campos,
City Clerk.
|
6:40 P.M.
Moment of
Silence |
Moment of silence in
memory of all the Tsunami victims in
Asia and the
Californians who have lost their lives during the recent storms.
|
301-1
Burbank
Tournament of
Roses Assn. |
Mayor Ramos
presented a Certificate of Recognition to Teri Bastion, President of the
Burbank Tournament of Roses Association, whose float �Dinner�s on �
FIRE!�
received the Founder�s Trophy for the most spectacular float built and
decorated by volunteers at the 2005 Tournament of Roses Parade.
|
301-1
St. Francis
Xavier Lancer
Flag Football
Team |
Mayor Ramos
presented Certificates of Recognition to the coaches and players of the
Saint Francis Xavier Lancer Flag Football Team, who were awarded first
place in the Catholic Youth Organization League playoffs out of 160
teams. Certificates were awarded to the following: Brett Ackerman;
Vincent Borgese; Donald Brolsma; Michael Diaz; Adam Dlugolecki; Tommy
Falchini; James Hunt; Jake Johnson; Trevor Johnson; Joey Kaufman; Michael
Magallon; Parnell Piano; Dillon Ross; Casey Ryan; Clinton Sharp; Nick
Viebahn; Drew Wagner; and, coaches John Ackerman, Ryan Ackerman, Mike
Graceffo,
Scott Konzen and Kyle Ryan. A certificate was also presented to Dr. Paul
Sullivan, Principal and recognition was given to Mitch Kellogg, Ball Boy.
|
301-1
Martin Luther
King, Jr. Day |
Mayor Ramos
presented a proclamation in honor of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day to: John
Brady, representing the Burbank Human Relations Council; Paula Bogar,
representing Forest Lawn; and, Barry Smedberg, representing the Valley
Interfaith Council.
|
Airport Authority Report
|
There was no report
given. |
7:13 P.M.
Hearing
1702
Platt Project
(PD 2003-1) |
Mayor Ramos stated that �this is the time and place for the public hearing
on the second reading of the proposed ordinance to approve Planned
Development No. 2003-1, and the related Development Agreement. The site
of the proposed project is the property bounded by Alameda Avenue, Lima
Street, Olive Avenue and property adjacent to the 134 Freeway off-ramp.
The applicant is PW LLC.
The purpose of this hearing is to hear additional public comments
regarding the proposed project, including comments to the modifications
made to the project at the conclusion of the Council hearing on December
7, 2004.�
|
Notice
Given |
The City Clerk was asked if notices had been given as required by law.
She replied in the affirmative and advised that the City Clerk�s Office
received 15 pieces of correspondence in opposition to the project and 18
pieces of correspondence in favor of the project.
|
Staff
Report |
Mrs. Forbes, Principal Planner, Community Development Department,
requested the Council consider the second reading of an ordinance to
approve a Planned Development project. She reported that on December 7,
2004, the Council held a public hearing to consider a proposal by PW, LLC
to construct a mixed used project and voted to: adopt the Water Supply
Assessment; certify the Environmental Impact Report (EIR); amend the
General Plan for this site to allow residential uses; conditionally vacate
the street and alleys contingent upon approval of the project;
conditionally approve the vesting tentative tract map contingent upon
approval of the project; and, complete a first reading to adopt the
ordinance approving the Planned Development with the accompanying
Development Agreement as conditioned by staff and modified by the Council.
Mrs. Forbes added that the modified project consists of: a reduction in
the number of residential units from 298 to 250; a church; child care
center for 72 children; and, approximately 20,000 square feet of retail
and restaurant space. She noted that the public health club facility was
eliminated. She explained that the uses will be located in five
buildings; two 50-feet buildings along Alameda Avenue, two 70-feet
buildings in the center of the project and one 103-feet building along
Olive Avenue and the State Route 134 Freeway. She added that the setbacks
along Alameda Avenue would be 10 feet for the church and 20 feet for the
residential building, a 10-foot setback along Lima street is required in
addition to a dedication as determined by staff, an average setback of
approximately 20 feet along Olive Avenue is required with a minimum
setback of 10 feet, and balconies would be permitted to encroach by three
feet into the 10-foot minimum setback requirement. She noted that two
parks would be provided on the site along Alameda Avenue and Olive Avenue;
however, the Olive Avenue park area would be reduced by a maximum of 1800
square feet to allow for the 103�foot building to become squatter.
Further, she reported that the applicant is required to complete the
project within one or two phases at most, and contribute $500,000 towards
a Media District shuttle service and $2.5 million toward affordable
housing within the City.
Mrs. Forbes informed the Council that an Addendum to the Environmental
Impact Report that was certified by the Council has been prepared stating
that the modifications made to the project at the December 7, 2004 public
hearing have been adequately studied and do not result in new or greater
significant impacts than those already identified. Specifically, she
elaborated on: the updated evaluation of traffic impacts; parking
requirement modifications; and, the updated view corridor analysis. She
also discussed the currently-modified project in comparison to a permitted
by-right project on the site. She noted that staff has prepared a
resolution modifying the California Environmental Quality Act findings to
more accurately depict the modified project.
|
|
Mr. Golonski, Ms. Murphy, Mr. Campbell, Mr. Vander Borght and Mrs. Ramos
disclosed meeting or communicating with the applicant or his
representative regarding the project.
|
Applicant
|
Dale Goldsmith, representing PW LLC, introduced his team members and
commended staff for their efforts regarding the project. He noted the
major modifications to the project since the original proposal in 2001 and
the additional Conditions of Approval placed on the project. He also
commented on the peak hour trip generations for the proposed project
compared to a by-right project and other projects in close proximity to
the subject site. He urged the Council to approve the project.
|
Citizen
Comment |
Appearing to comment
in support of the project were: Wayne Schultze; Dorinda Carey; Yvette
Salmon; Robert Hooven; Erick Lofstrand; Reagan Holmes; Miriam Schoengarth;
Rick Brown; and, Chris Baer.
Commenting in
opposition to the project were: Michael Anderson; Lauren Lacher; Jeannie
Davis; Rick Lacher; Chris Vose; David Heisy; Nancy Lacher; Mark Welles;
Debra Scarlata; Patrika Darbo; Ken Hoaglund; Rose Prouser; Jesse Byers;
Mary-Ann Christ; Ron Vanderford; Brian Sprow; Joseph Ricciardella; Phil
Berlin; Rolf Darbo; Mark Stebbeds; Michael Bergfeld; Robert Magid; Alice
Howell; Eden Rosen; Jennifer Sprow; David Piroli; Mike Nolan; and, Wynn
Hammer. Also, Mark Barton, offered to make a model of the project as
currently proposed.
|
Hearing
Closed |
There being no further response to the Mayor�s invitation for oral
comment, the hearing was declared closed.
|
Rebuttal by
Applicant |
Dale Goldsmith, representing PW LLC, made rebuttal comments with regard
to: response to community concerns; further reductions to the height and
density; and, traffic/trip generation. He noted that the project will
contribute $500,000 towards mass transit, have a shuttle stop on site,
fund a Neighborhood Protection Plan and represent smart growth. He
reiterated the applicant�s willingness to work with the neighborhood in
the design process.
|
Staff Response |
Mrs. Forbes responded to public comment with regard to: the community
participating in the design process noting that expert architects on
contract with the City will also provide input; Media District Specific
Plan (MDSP) compatibility; the view corridor study analysis; affordable
housing contribution; maintaining the project�s density; by-right
development; approving the project without specific plans; the height of
the Pinnacle Project; shade and shadow impacts; and, the developer�s
proposal for a flat roof design.
|
Council
Deliberations |
Mr. Campbell
requested a status update on the Neighborhood Protection Plan and
clarification on the MDSP amendment and the associated noticing procedure,
and the design plan submittals.
Ms. Murphy requested
clarification on the proposed park maintenance.
Mr. Tony
Loccarciardo, Principal with Impact Sciences, elaborated on the EIR
analysis with regard to cumulative impacts.
Mr. Golonski
responded to comments regarding density and lot coverage. He noted that
the major concerns expressed included: MDSP compatibility; the height and
density of the project being excessive; excessive traffic; and, lack of a
specific design for the project. He was supportive of amending the MDSP
to allow for a better project.
Ms. Murphy expressed
disappointment with the applicant�s failure to provide more specific
information on the project as requested at the
December 7, 2004
meeting.
Mr. Vander Borght
noted that prior Councils have approved project conceptual plans without
completed design plans. He added that the MDSP was intended primarily as
a means of protecting the neighborhood while allowing reasonable growth in
the area. He expressed a desire to further reduce the height limit for
the tallest building to 93 feet but would still consider the project,
noting that a by-right development would generate almost twice the peak
hour traffic that the proposed project will generate. He clarified that
the height limit was defined as the maximum envelope including parapets
and elevator shafts with nothing protruding beyond the permitted height.
He also indicated support for further reducing the density to 220 units
or postponing the item pending more specific information from the
developer.
Mr. Campbell
similarly expressed concern with the potential impacts of a by-right
development. He noted the challenge of considering a project without
design plans and was supportive of postponing the item pending further
information. He indicated support for the 93-foot, 70-foot and 50-foot
height envelopes, the 220 units, and subsequent community input regarding
the project.
Mrs. Ramos requested
further clarification on the by-right project and the shared parking
analysis. She supported the proposed reductions in height and units and
amending the MDSP to allow residential use. She expressed concern with
the potential traffic impacts and the implications of a by-right project.
She was also supportive of postponing the project�s approval until
further information is provided.
|
10:44 P.M.
Recess |
The Council recessed at this time. The meeting reconvened at 10:57 p.m.
with all members present.
|
Council
Deliberations
Continued |
Dale Goldsmith, representing PW LLC,
conceded to the
93-foot height envelope for the tallest building but requested flexibility
with regard to the number of units, stating his preference for approval to
build up to 250 units. He also requested that the applicant be allowed to
construct the 50-foot and 70-foot buildings per the Burbank Municipal
Code. He urged the Council to approve the project.
Mr. Golonski was
supportive of the 93-foot envelope limit and the 220 maximum units. He
also concurred with postponing the item to allow the developer to provide
more information, but noted the need to maintain the quality of the
project.
The Council
concurred that a decision on the project be postponed and expressed
support for the 93-foot, 50-foot and 70-foot height envelopes and a limit
of 220 units without compromising the project�s quality. The Council also
directed that the developer provide a massing model at the next hearing in
relation to the residential properties across the street.
|
Motion |
It was moved by Mr. Campbell, seconded by Mr. Vander Borght and carried
that "this item be continued to the February 8, 2005 Council meeting.�
|
Reporting on
Closed Session |
Mr. Barlow reported on the items considered by the City Council and the
Redevelopment Agency during the Closed Session meetings.
|
Initial Open
Public Comment
Period of Oral
Communications |
Mrs. Ramos called for speakers for the initial open public comment period
of oral communications at this time.
|
Citizen
Comment |
Appearing to comment were:
Ron Vanderford, on
the upcoming elections; Eden Rosen, on Charter Communications� cable
subscription increase and traffic issues; Mark Barton, on working with
developers; James Schad, on the disposal of diesel fuel in the Los Angeles
River behind Warner Bros.; Rose Prouser, on Airport matters; Phil Berlin,
on the Platt Project; and, Mark Stebbeds, on the sale of the B-6 property.
|
Staff
Response |
Members of the Council and staff responded to questions raised.
|
Agenda Item
Oral Communications |
Mrs. Ramos called for speakers for the agenda item oral communications at
this time.
|
Citizen
Comment |
Appearing to comment were:
Chris Carson, in
support of the League of Women Voters conducting candidate forums for the
Primary Nominating and General Municipal Elections; Mark Stebbeds, on
Airport issues; Mark Barton, on the massing model of the proposed Platt
project; Eden Rosen, on the Platt project; Rose Prouser, on Airport
issues; Mike Nolan, on Airport issues and his right to speak during a
Council recess; and, David Piroli, on Airport issues.
|
Staff
Response |
Members of the Council and staff responded to questions raised.
|
Jt. Mtg. with
Redev. Agency
1102
603
Loans for Non-
Profit Organizations |
Ms. Frausto, Administrative Analyst, Community Development Department,
requested Council direction regarding a request by Mayor Ramos at the
November 2, 2004 Council meeting, for the Council and Redevelopment Agency
Board to discuss the possibility of establishing a low-interest loan
program for local community-based non-profit organizations to purchase or
build new facilities.
Staff was directed to return with a report.
|
Motion |
It was moved by Mr. Campbell and seconded by Ms. Murphy that "the
following items on the consent calendar be approved as recommended,� with
Mr. Golonski abstaining on the League of Women Voters to Conduct Candidate
Forums.
|
1208-1
1302
Acquisition and
Settlement Agmt. for 206
E. Cedar Ave. |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,856:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK APPROVING THE PURCHASE
AND SALE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF BURBANK AND GREG AND LINDA OWENS
(461 NORTH VARNEY STREET).
|
1411-1
Reso. of Intent
For V-364
(Warner Bros.) |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,857:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK DECLARING ITS INTENTION
TO CONSIDER THE CONDITIONAL VACATION OF A PORTION OF THE RIGHT-OF-WAY
ALONG CORDOVA STREET BETWEEN OLIVE AVENUE AND WARNER BOULEVARD, AND
RESERVING A PUBLIC UTILITY EASEMENT (V-364).
|
1101-2
Amend PSA w/
Ultrasystems for
EIR for Mobility
And Land Use
Elements |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,858:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK APPROVING THE TENTH
AMENDMENT TO THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF
BURBANK AND ULTRASYSTEMS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. FOR THE PREPARATION OF AN
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT.
|
1212-2
Multi-Lease Agmt.
with OCE
For Color Copier |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,859:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK APPROVING THE FIVE YEAR
LEASE BETWEEN THE CITY OF BURBANK AND OCE NORTH AMERICA, INC. TO LEASE A
COLOR COPIER AND ACQUIRE DOCWORKS SOFTWARE.
|
804-3
907
DOJ Grant for
Bulletproof Vest
Program |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,860:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK AMENDING THE FISCAL
YEAR 2004-2005 BUDGET FOR THE PURPOSE OF RECEIVING AND APPROPRIATING
BULLETPROOF VEST GRANT PROGRAM FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT OF $6,689.01 FROM THE
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, BUREAU OF JUSTICE ASSISTANCE.
|
1007-1
Re-titling the
Spec. for Water
Production/
Operations
Superintendent |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,861:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK REVISING AND RE-TITLING
THE SPECIFICATION FOR THE CLASSIFICATION OF WATER PRODUCTION/OPERATIONS
SUPERINTENDENT (CTC No. 0992) TO MANAGER WATER PRODUCTION/OPERATIONS (CTC
No. 0536).
|
1204-1
Approval of
Tract Map No.
53957 (528 E.
Cedar Ave.) |
RESOLUTION NO. 26,862:
A RESOLUTION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BURBANK APPROVING THE FINAL MAP
OF TRACT NO. 53957 (528 EAST CEDAR AVENUE).
|
204
Request from
League of
Women Voters
To Conduct
Candidate Forums
|
A report was
received from the Public Information Office regarding a request from the
League of Women Voters of Glendale/Burbank (League) to cablecast candidate
forums for the offices of City Council Member and Burbank Unified School
District Board Member for the primary and general elections. The report
indicated that the League requested to cablecast the forums live on
February 2, 2005 and
March 30, 2005. The report further indicated that the cost incurred by
the City to produce, broadcast and replay the forum on Channel 6 is
approximately $395.
|
Adopted |
The consent calendar was adopted by the following vote:
Ayes: Council Members
Campbell, Golonski, Murphy,
Vander Borght and Ramos.
Noes: Council Members None.
Absent: Council Members None.
Mr. Golonski abstained on the League of Women Voters Request to Conduct
Candidate Forums.
|
12:18 A.M.
Reconvene Redev.
Agency Meeting |
The Redevelopment Agency meeting was reconvened at this time.
|
Final Open
Public Comment
Period of Oral
Communications |
Mrs. Ramos called for speakers for the final open public comment period of
oral communications at this time.
|
Citizen
Comment |
Appearing to comment was
Mike Nolan, on
disruptive conduct in the Council Chamber.
|
Staff
Response
|
Members of the Council and staff responded to questions raised.
|
Adjournment |
There being no further business to come before the Council, the meeting
was adjourned at 12:20 a.m. to Wednesday, January 12, 2005, 5:30 p.m., at
the Buena Vista Library, 300 North Buena Vista Street, for an open house
and 7:00 p.m. for a townhall forum on the proposed Airport Development
Agreement and related actions.
__________________________________
Margarita Campos, CMC, City Clerk
|